Making Group Work Fair and Productive

group work strategies in the classroom

You’ve seen it: one student does everything while the rest coast. The best group work strategies in the classroom fix this with shared goals, clear roles and individual accountability.

This guide is part of the wider set of teaching tips on this site.

Item Value
Key elements that separate cooperative learning from plain grouping Five
Kagan’s memory aid for those elements PIES (positive interdependence, individual accountability, equal participation, simultaneous interaction)
Ways to build positive interdependence Four: output goal, learning goal, resource and role
Core accountability principle “Students learn together, but perform alone”
Effect of unstructured group work on learning Little or no effect, according to repeated findings

These figures come from Carleton College’s SERC guide to cooperative learning and the ASCB Life Sciences Education guide on group work accountability. Pages get updated, so check the sources before you rely on them.

Why group work needs structure

Putting desks together is not the same as teaching students to collaborate. SERC explains that cooperative learning requires teachers to structure interdependence, and it names five key elements that set it apart from simply putting students into groups, as set out on the SERC cooperative learning page.

  • Positive interdependence: students feel they “sink or swim together”.
  • Individual accountability: each student answers for their own learning.
  • Face-to-face interaction: students explain and discuss ideas with each other.
  • Interpersonal and small-group skills: leadership, decision-making, trust-building, communication and conflict management.
  • Group processing: time to review how the group worked.

The stakes are real. The ASCB guide reports that unstructured group work, where students are told to work together but have few incentives to do so, has repeatedly been shown to have little or no effect on learning.

Kagan’s acronym PIES compresses the same ideas into something easy to recall: positive interdependence, individual accountability, equal participation and simultaneous interaction. Pin it above your planning notes and check each group task against it.

Build interdependence into the task

Students work together properly when the task needs everyone. SERC says you will know you have succeeded when students feel they “sink or swim together”, and that group members should believe each person’s efforts benefit everyone.

The same SERC page lists four ways to create that dependence:

  • Output goal: the group produces a single product.
  • Learning goal: the group makes sure every member can explain the product.
  • Resource: members get different parts of the information, or the group gets only one copy of the assignment.
  • Role: members hold distinct roles that the group needs in order to function.

A jigsaw is a classic way to combine these. You divide the material into specialist areas, students become experts in one area together, then return to their home groups to combine what they know and finish the project.

group work strategies in the classroom Table discussion
Four students sit around a classroom table with papers spread between them.

Task design matters as much as roles. The ASCB guide says tasks should not be completable by just one or two members, but should require contributions from everyone, which in turn demands communication and coordination.

Make every student accountable

The accountability test is simple: “students learn together, but perform alone”. That wording from SERC means nobody can hitch-hike on the work of others, because each student must show what they personally learned.

The ASCB guide adds that knowing you are responsible for your own contribution reduces social free-riding and encourages members to contribute. A small study it summarises (Harkins and Jackson) found that participants who thought their outputs were being evaluated against others generated more outputs than those who did not.

SERC suggests several practical ways to build this in:

  • Give individual quizzes or exams alongside the group project.
  • Have parts of the project completed independently.
  • Draw students at random to report the group’s results, orally or in writing.
  • Ask students to rate their group mates anonymously and count the average rating as part of each student’s grade.

Peer ratings only help if students know what useful comments sound like, so it pays to teach how to give effective feedback to students before they rate each other.

For larger projects, the ASCB guide recommends milestones and deadlines for groups, plus time for students to assign duties and roles themselves. That balance gives groups structure without taking away their autonomy.

Teach teamwork skills and review how it went

Students learn the subject (taskwork) and also how to work together (teamwork). SERC notes that teachers can encourage much higher performance by teaching cooperative skills within the lessons, rather than assuming students already have them.

Three habits make that easier:

  1. Explain why students are working together and how the group can help their learning.
  2. Keep groups together for a series of projects, so members learn each other’s schedules and strengths and ask better questions of one another.
  3. Close each task with group processing: time and a procedure for judging how well the group functioned and how well social skills were used.

SERC also suggests that students write individual, private reflections after a project, naming which parts of the work and which group mates contributed to discoveries, before the group discusses it together.

Skills stick when the mechanics are predictable. Treat entering groups, moving furniture and handing in work as part of your classroom routines and procedures, so lesson time goes to the learning.

What does the research say about roles, rewards and grouping?

The evidence supports structure, though it is not uniform. A review in the ASCB guide covers five studies comparing structured and unstructured groups. Students in structured groups showed more cooperative behaviour, were less likely to work independently of the group, and helped their peers more often.

Roles may also raise interaction. In an online study of 289 undergraduate business majors across 47 course sections, students in groups with assigned roles and rewards interacted significantly more often than those with rewards alone or with no structured interdependence, as summarised by ASCB.

Some findings are less clear-cut. One college life science study summarised there found no significant difference between mixed-ability and similar-ability groups, and no difference between groups with and without cooperative incentives. Treat grouping and reward choices as things to test in your own class rather than fixed rules.

Frequently asked questions

How do I stop one student doing all the work?

Show answer

Make the task need everyone and make each student answerable for their share. Sources recommend individual quizzes, randomly chosen reporters, and anonymous peer ratings counted toward the grade.

Should I grade the group product or individuals?

Show answer

SERC describes both. Part of each student’s grade can depend on the group’s performance to build interdependence, while individual assessments keep accountability clear.

Do I need to assign roles?

Show answer

Roles are one recommended option. SERC gives examples such as checking data, keeping the group on task or keeping records, and they require students to interact with the rest of the group.

How long should groups stay together?

Show answer

SERC suggests assigning groups early in the term and letting them complete a series of projects together, so members learn each other’s strengths and ask better questions.