Giving Feedback That Helps Students Improve

how to give effective feedback to students

Wondering how to give effective feedback to students so it actually changes their work? Tie every comment to the goal, show them where they stand and what to do next, and deliver it soon after the task.

This guide sits within the wider set of teaching tips on this site.

Item Value
Effect size of feedback in Hattie’s meta-analysis 1.13
Effect size usually considered ‘large’ 0.6 or greater
Core questions in the Hattie and Timperley model 3 (Where am I going? How am I going? Where to next?)
Levels at which feedback can be addressed 4
Year of the Hattie and Timperley framework 2007

These figures come from the NSW Department of Education feedback page and the ACT Education Directorate workshop page. Figures can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

Why the type of feedback matters

In Hattie’s meta-analysis of influences on student achievement, feedback sits at the top with an effect size of 1.13, and the NSW Department of Education notes that an effect size of 0.6 or greater is usually considered ‘large’.

The catch is that the impact can run either way. Hattie and Timperley’s review of feedback says its effect can be positive or negative, and that the type of feedback and the way it is given make the difference.

That is why quality beats quantity. The NSW page cites the view that bad feedback can be worse than no feedback, and that useful feedback is frequent, constructive and instructive.

Descriptive feedback, which focuses on what needs to be done, is described there as the most powerful tool for improving learning. It can encourage students to believe they can improve.

Three questions every comment should answer

The ACT Education Directorate summarises the Hattie and Timperley model by saying effective feedback must answer three major questions:

  • Where am I going? What are my goals? (sometimes called feed up)
  • How am I going? What progress is being made toward the goal? (feedback)
  • Where to next? What activities will make better progress? (feed forward)

The main purpose of feedback is to reduce the gap between current understanding or performance and the goal. The ideal learning environment is one where both teachers and students seek answers to each question.

Before you write a comment, check that you could answer all three in a sentence each. If a comment answers none of them, it is probably decoration.

Tie feedback to the goal and success criteria

According to the NSW Department of Education, effective feedback should relate specifically to a learning intention or goal and the associated success criteria. Comments that drift away from the goal use up your time and the student’s attention.

The ACT resource gives a clear example. If the success criteria ask for “creating mood in a story”, feedback on presentation, spelling and word count does not reduce the gap relating to that intention.

Specific goals also work better than general ones for focusing students’ attention, and they allow more directed feedback. A clear rubric or marking scheme is the easiest way to keep goals concise.

how to give effective feedback to students Individual guidance
An adult leans beside a child and points toward the paper the child is working on.

Choose the level of your comment

The ACT resource describes four levels at which feedback can be addressed. Task-level feedback tells students how well a task was done, such as distinguishing correct from incorrect answers, and it is the most frequent kind.

Teachers commonly mix corrective feedback with feedback aimed at the person, which dilutes the power of the task feedback. A comment that bundles “that is correct” with praise for the student is a typical example.

Task feedback has limits too. It is not as effective as process-level or self-regulation feedback because it often does not generalise to other tasks, though it can still be a strong foundation.

Some habits that keep each comment clean:

  • Keep corrective comments about the work, not the student.
  • Add a strategy or process prompt, so the comment helps beyond this one task.
  • Ask students to check their own work, building the error detection that leads to self-feedback.

Make it timely and give students something to do

The NSW page says feedback should be timely, meaning immediate or soon after the action. Spoken feedback is useful here because it gives you a chance to check in and see whether the feedback was understood.

Pairing comments with strong questioning techniques for teachers can help you find out whether a student has actually taken the comment on board.

The ACT resource says the “where to next” question can have some of the most powerful impacts on learning. Good feed forward can lead to:

  • enhanced challenges
  • more self-regulation over the learning process
  • more strategies and processes for working on tasks
  • deeper understanding
  • more information about what is and is not understood

Error detection is most powerful when students have a workable amount of knowledge about the task. If you want students to practise spotting errors together, group work strategies in the classroom offer structures to try.

A simple routine to try

  1. Share the goal and success criteria before the task starts.
  2. Respond only to those criteria when you review the work.
  3. Write a descriptive comment that says what to do next.
  4. Return it soon after the task, ideally with a short spoken check-in.
  5. Give students time to act on the comment and show you what changed.

The ACT resource also lists approaches unlikely to help: blurring the learning goals, making goals so big that students pick and choose, and letting students shrink the challenge or accept performance far below their capabilities.

Frequently asked questions

Can feedback make learning worse?

Show answer

Yes. Hattie and Timperley’s review says feedback can have a positive or negative impact, and the NSW page cites the view that bad feedback can be worse than no feedback.

Is praise enough?

Show answer

Not on its own. Descriptive feedback that focuses on what needs to be done is described as the most powerful tool, and mixing praise for the person into corrective comments dilutes the task feedback.

How soon should feedback arrive?

Show answer

Return it right after the task or shortly afterwards, rather than leaving a long gap before students see your comments. A quick spoken check-in on the day is one way to do that.

Should feedback be spoken or written?

Show answer

Either can work, since feedback can take many forms. The NSW page notes that oral feedback lets you check whether it has been understood.