Classroom Management Strategies That Build Respect

classroom management strategies

You want a calm room without becoming the class enforcer. The classroom management strategies that hold up in research are specific, proactive and respectful: define the behavior, shape the setting, teach skills, keep students engaged.

This guide is part of our collection of teaching tips, and it walks through the research-backed approach step by step.

Item Value
Evidence-based strategies in the IES blog post 5 strategies
Blog post publication date November 19, 2019
Practice guide the strategies draw on NCEE #2008-012
Class size that makes individual needs hard to track 30 plus students
Students some teachers see in a day More than 100 students

The figures come from the IES blog post on five classroom management strategies and the definition from the SAGE Encyclopedia of Classroom Management. Figures and guidance can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

What classroom management means, and what it does not

Diane Myers and Brandi Simonsen define classroom management as the way a teacher designs the academic and social components of instruction to encourage and maintain appropriate student behavior. The focus is on design, not on reaction.

They also separate it from discipline. Management is a proactive, systematic approach to supporting students’ behavioral needs, while discipline is the application of consequences for rule-violating behavior.

That distinction is where respect starts. When most of the work happens before a rule is broken, there can be fewer moments when a student has to be corrected in front of peers.

The five strategies below come from a blog post by REL Appalachia, published November 19, 2019 on the IES site. It draws on an IES practice guide, Reducing Behavior Problems in the Elementary School Classroom, and on a systematic literature search by Simonsen and colleagues, Evidence-based Practices in Classroom Management: Considerations for Research to Practice.

Name the behavior before you respond to it

The first strategy is to be specific about the problem. Instead of noting that a student is “disruptive,” track what the behavior is, when it happens and how often.

Once that is written down, ask two questions about the pattern:

  • What is prompting the student to act out?
  • What is reinforcing the behavior?

The IES post offers two examples. A student may blurt out answers without raising a hand every day during whole-class instruction, or a student may struggle to line up quietly for lunch or recess.

For the blurting, the teacher can remind the whole class to raise hands, acknowledge students who do, and avoid praising correct answers shouted out of turn. For the line, the teacher might give the student the role of line leader during transitions to non-academic activities, so the student practices the expected behavior.

The post notes that research suggests tailoring an intervention to an individual student’s distinct needs is more effective than a blanket intervention. It adds that strategies not linked to a specific problem behavior can increase the unwanted behavior rather than decrease it.

Set up the room and the day for success

The second strategy asks whether the setting is part of the problem. According to the post, triggers can result from a mismatch between the classroom setting or academic demand and students’ strengths, preferences or skills.

Three examples from the post show what that looks like:

  • Students may be unfocused because they are doing an academically demanding activity at the very end of the day.
  • The room may be arranged so the teacher cannot walk around smoothly and monitor engagement.
  • Transition time between activities may be disrupting students’ attention.

To act on this, the post advises revisiting and regularly reinforcing behavioral expectations, checking that the environment is not the source of problem behavior, and varying instructional strategies to create more chances for success and engagement.

classroom management strategies Individual instruction
A teacher stands beside a whiteboard facing a seated student.

Teach and reinforce the behavior you want

Management begins with expectations for success. When students miss them, the post says modeling and reinforcing positive behavior is one strategy that can lead to a more positive classroom climate.

Its example is a teacher saying, “you’ve been doing so well raising your hand when you want to speak, you get to take a short break and go to the water fountain.” The praise names the behavior and makes clear what earned the reward.

The post describes three steps for putting this into practice:

  1. Identify where a student needs explicit instruction.
  2. Provide examples, practice and feedback.
  3. Make sure reinforcers are provided for appropriate behavior and withheld for inappropriate behavior.

Feedback of this kind lands better when students trust you, and the guide on how to build teacher-student relationships covers that groundwork.

Keep students actively engaged

The fourth strategy rests on a simple claim from the post: when students are actively engaged in academic work, it is difficult for them to engage in disruptive behavior.

It gives two concrete tools. Students can answer questions in real time on individual erasable boards, which requires active participation, or they can follow a lecture outline and fill in details as it progresses.

Increasing students’ opportunities to respond and providing guided notes can both support active participation and reduce disruption. For more ideas on drawing students in, see the piece on how to engage students in learning.

Can colleagues and families really help?

The fifth strategy admits that this is hard work. The post points out that with a class of 30 plus, or more than 100 students a day, it is difficult to understand each student’s strengths and behavioral triggers.

Its suggestions are practical:

  • Compare notes with colleagues about what has worked with specific students.
  • Encourage family members to engage in teaching and reinforcing appropriate behavior.
  • Ask families which strategies work at home, then try them at school.

Parents, school personnel and behavioral experts can all be allies. The post says these relationships can help ease teacher stress and burnout from handling chronic or serious behavior problems.

Frequently asked questions

Is classroom management the same as discipline?

Show answer

No. According to Myers and Simonsen in the SAGE Encyclopedia of Classroom Management, management is a proactive, systematic approach to supporting behavioral needs, while discipline is the application of consequences for rule-violating behavior.

Which strategy should I start with?

Show answer

Start by naming the specific behavior, when it happens and how often. The IES post says a response tailored to the behavior is more effective than a blanket intervention, so the other strategies work better once you know what you are solving.

What if one student’s behavior keeps happening?

Show answer

Check whether the setting or the timing of the task is a trigger, then compare notes with colleagues and ask the family what works at home. The IES post names parents, school personnel and behavioral experts as allies for this.

Do these strategies only apply to elementary classrooms?

Show answer

The practice guide behind the post focuses on the elementary school classroom, so adapt the ideas with judgment for other grades. The post itself also mentions teachers who see more than 100 students a day, which describes a very different schedule from a single elementary class.